Brighton and Hove Albion: A Knight to the Rescue

Brighton & Hove Albion’s Memorable FA Cup Run of 1983

For those of a certain age, it’s hard to mention Brighton & Hove Albion without bringing to mind their heroic FA Cup run of the early 1980s. Everyone likes an underdog and when Albion came up against the might of Manchester United,  it’s safe to assume that most people were rooting for the Seagulls. And this wasn’t just because they had been relegated from the old First Division that season, although that helped. It was also because this was the first (and subsequently only) time that Albion had made it all the way to the final.

In the end the Seagulls came very close to a huge upset. In the dying seconds of extra time, with the score at 2-2, Brighton’s Gordon Smith was put clear on goal with only the goalkeeper to beat. Rather than hit it first time, a decision that would probably have seen the ball safely into the back of the net, Smith took one touch too many and ended up having his shot smothered by the body of the advancing United keeper. The replay a few days later wasn’t anywhere near as close, and United battered their opponents 4-0. But the scale of the defeat combined with the memory of how close Brighton had come to claiming the Cup only served to endear the club to neutrals that bit more.

Brighton’s Decline and the Loss of the Goldstone Ground

Until recent years, that cup run, and time in the top flight, would be a high for the fans of the Albion. Their relegation marked the beginnings of a decline that wouldn’t show signs of abating until the early years of the new millennium. In the 20 years that followed the drop,  the Seagulls would endure relegations, false dawns, successive bouts of financial crisis and, perhaps worst of all, the loss of their stadium.

For those who regard a football stadium as something more than bricks and mortar, the site of the Goldstone Ground today would be sure to depress. The Goldstone Retail Park, which now stands in place of Brighton’s former spiritual home, is a great place for anyone who wants to buy a washing machine, do a bit of DIY and then top their shopping trip off with a flaccid burger. But it’s not so good for anyone who thinks that football stadiums should be permanent, a physical link with a club’s history.

Why Brighton Sold the Goldstone Ground in 1995

The announcement that Brighton were upping sticks, flogging their stadium and entering a ground-share with Portsmouth was broken to supporters in the summer of 1995.

‘It came as real shock, a huge bolt out of the blue,’ explained Liz Costa, of the Brighton Supporters’ Club (who spoke to me back in 2014)

A few years earlier two directors at the club, Greg Stanley and Bill Archer, had taken over, stepping in to rescue the Seagulls from a winding-up order (with Archer installed as chairman).

‘The new regime had apparently invested £800,000 and promised to turn things around. Although at the time we saw precious little sign of things improving, there was still a feeling that the club wasn’t in too bad a- shape. That’s part of the reason why it came as such a shock when the sale of the stadium was announced,’ stressed Costa.

It was claimed by the owners, principally through their mouthpiece at the club, CEO David Bellotti, that Albion needed to sell the Goldstone because there was too much debt, a figure that they said stood at around £6m. To placate the fans, alongside the announcement concerning the sale, the club also revealed their long-term plans to build a new 30,000 all- seater stadium in the west of the city.

Brighton Fans Challenge the Club’s Owners

But the devil, as least for fans, was in the detail. As more was revealed about the sale and planned move, much of it dug up by the supporters themselves, it became clear that not all was how it seemed.

To begin with, it was discovered that far from arriving and saving the club with fresh investment, the new owners had in fact merely restructured Albion’s finances and taken on an £800,000 bank loan to do so, a move that hardly helped the club’s long-term financial position. The reality was that the new owners had probably put less into the club than some supporters. Archer, for example, had acquired his 56 per cent holding in Brighton for the princely sum of just £56.

Although no malicious intent was ever established, the owners hardly endeared themselves to the fans when it was also discovered that the Articles of Association of the club’s holding company, Foray 585, had been altered to remove the prohibition against owners profiting from the sale of club assets, such as the stadium (in direct defiance of the FA’s Rule 34). Although the articles were later corrected, the affair left a bad taste in the mouth for many fans.

There was also a sense that the owners were not being frank about future plans for a new stadium. Not only had no one explained how a club that was near bankrupt could afford to build a brand new ground, on successive occasions it was discovered that the owners’ much- trumpeted plans (several of which appeared during their tenure at the club) had either been rebuffed by the local authority or were completely impractical from a planning perspective.

‘So what you had,’ explained Costa, ‘was a regime in charge at the club that no one believed was capable of telling the truth and which appeared to have no real plans to turn the club around and build strong foundations for the future. It was a recipe for conflict.’

And that’s exactly what happened. During the 1996/97 campaign, the last that Albion played at the Goldstone, the fans undertook a season of protest against the board. The various demonstrations (which admirably never turned violent) took place all over the country and included a protest outside Archer’s Lancashire home, marches through Brighton and London, petitions to the FA, and a rally outside of the Crewe HQ of Focus DIY, Archer’s company. There were also regular demonstrations inside the Goldstone on match days.

Despite the protests, media hostility and support from across the game, the board remained defiant and the final game at the Goldstone took place on 26 April 1997, a 1-0 victory over Doncaster Rovers. Once the final whistle had blown, the home fans ransacked the stadium, many of them in tears. Most supporters, especially those who have endured an experience similar to that meted out to the Brighton faithful, can probably appreciate this need to claim a piece of what was being taken away from them. The Goldstone was later demolished in 1998, making way for the shoppers’ paradise that stands there today.

Dick Knight’s Campaign to Save Brighton & Hove Albion

But not all hope was lost, as Liz Costa explained, ‘Although we’d just become homeless, the fans  had received some welcome news towards the end of the season when it was announced that Archer had lost control of the club.’

Since the spring of 1996 a consortium put together and fronted by local businessman and lifelong Brighton supporter, Dick Knight, had been attempting to remove the owners and put a new regime in place.

‘Like a lot of fans I was horrified by what was going on at Brighton. I’d been a supporter for many years and could still clearly recall the excitement I’d felt when I’d been taken to my first game by my dad aged eight. The Albion were my club and it just saddened me to see them in such a mess', Knight exlained to me back in 2014. 

Knight was approached to get involved in efforts to oust Archer by Brighton’s former manager, Liam Brady, who retained a soft spot for the club.

‘Through all the years of support that followed, in my wildest dreams I’d not once ever pictured myself as chairman,’ said Knight. ‘It honestly hadn’t crossed my mind. But then my brother-in-law, who knew Liam, suggested that I be sounded out about maybe getting involved in Liam’s plans. I talked over his ideas with him and he really got me thinking about things.

‘It was clear that someone had to confront Archer head on and that someone had to be a fan, somebody who understood what this club meant to the people who followed it. It was also clear that Liam needed someone working with him, to show some leadership to get an effective group of people together, people who could take on the odious regime. So when Liam finally asked me the question, whether I was in or out, there was no other response than to say “yes”. As a fan, it was my duty to do what I could.’

The consortium’s efforts to take control at the club were fiercely resisted by Archer, who seemed inured to the increasing hostility of the crowd.

‘I think he actually wanted to bait the fans. That’s the only reason I can think of to explain the way he acted.‘At the time, Archer was building up his DIY empire and every instance of conflict raised his profile that bit more, so possibly that was the motivation behind his attitude towards the supporters, which at times was simply inflammatory', thoght Knight.

The problem for the club was the stark divide that existed during negotiations, with Archer determined to remain in control and the Knight consortium loath to accept anything less than 100 per cent ownership of the club.

‘Although Archer only owned 56 per cent of the business, he effectively controlled the rest of it. And the nature of the business meant that if he didn’t want to sell then there was nothing we could do about it. In fact, he didn’t even have to talk to us, and for a long time that’s just what happened,’ explained Knight.

Dismayed at the impasse, the FA, which had been pretty ineffectual until that point, employed the Centre for Dispute Resolution to try and mediate between both sides. Against expectations, they secured an agreement for the future of the club. While Archer retained a shareholding, Knight’s consortium gained de facto control, with Knight appointed chairman. To the fans’ delight, David Bellotti was dismissed as part of the deal. Although Archer managed to hang around until 2002, when he was eventually bought out, his role and influence was greatly diminished and the supporters very quickly came to realise that their chief tormentor had been defeated.

Liz Costa: ‘Although Archer was still involved with the Albion and the Goldstone seemed lost (which it eventually was), the supporters felt that the club had turned a corner. We had faith in the new owners. Dick Knight was a totally different kind of man to Archer. He was communicative, honest and a man who carried through on his promises. But perhaps more than that, he was also a fan. Essentially, he was one of us.’

Dick Knight: ‘It had taken 18 months and plenty of hard work but finally we’d triumphed. I felt that the club could now start to rebuild and also repair the relationship with the supporters. At no time in the history of this club could I recall such a breakdown in relations between the fans and the board. Archer had gone out of his way to create this situation and it was now up to us, as real fans, to put it right. But before any of that could be done we had one very important task to achieve, and that was to make sure that Brighton would be playing in the Football League come the following campaign.’

Brighton’s Fight to Avoid Relegation in 1997

During the season, the team’s form had deteriorated markedly and for much of the campaign Brighton had struggled at the wrong end of the table. The victory over Doncaster during that final day at the Goldstone had thrown the club a lifeline, lifting them off the bottom of the Third Division and setting up a tantalising head-to-head against Hereford United the following weekend, where a point would prevent relegation to the Conference.

To add a little extra jeopardy to proceedings, the fixture that would decide Brighton’s fate had neatly pitted the two candidates for the drop against each other on the final Saturday of the season. Most of the media attention had been focused firmly on Brighton, their loss of stadium and the fact that they had once been a top flight side exercising the minds of most journalists. But Hereford’s decline, although not as dramatic, was still a surprise for most with an interest in the lower leagues.

The previous campaign had seen the Bulls challenging for a play-off place and during the early part of the season that followed it appeared that their good form would continue. But a disastrous reversal of fortunes towards the end of the season had dragged them into the relegation zone and this nail-biting head-to-head.

Around 4,000 Brighton fans made the trip west and for the first 45 minutes they must have wondered why they bothered. The away side were over-run from the off, a tentative midfield capitulating under the advancing Hereford hoard. When the home side scored in the 21st minute there was an air of inevitability about it, even if the goal was a horribly scrappy affair that ultimately went in off a Brighton defender. The away side went in at half-time despondent, knowing that if things continued in this way after the break then relegation was a certainty.

In his autobiography Madman, Dick Knight recalls what happened next:

‘The second half began. Immediately we were more positive, putting pressure on the fairly fragile Hereford defence, who sat further and further back and encouraged us to come forward. And the Albion fans roared them on… And then in the 63rd minute, we scored: Craig Maskell collected a weak clearance, took the ball on his knee and hit a left-foot volley past the keeper, Andy De Bont, which came back from his left-hand post across the goal. And Robbie Reinelt [only just on as a substitute] went for the rebound. I just had a feeling, when he was sprinting forward, that he was going to win the race with the defenders to the ball and bury it. And he did.’

Brighton spent the rest of the game dug in, thwarting everything that Hereford threw at them. When the final whistle blew the score remained 1-1 and with that the visitors were safe and the home side consigned to spend the following season in the Conference.

‘We were all on a high after that game. But despite that, the reality was that the situation was still pretty dire,’ admited Knight.

Brighton’s Groundshare at Gillingham and Financial Crisis

The club were now homeless and the only ground-share available to them was at Gillingham’s Priestfield Stadium. For anyone who doesn’t know this part of the south east, the ground-share represented a 150-mile round trip for Brighton fans, a huge journey to undertake every fortnight.

Knight said, ‘Not only that, but the club would be facing rental costs and a huge loss of earnings. But even this only represented part of our problems. We also had a squad of players that were not the best. Even our first XI was pretty poor. It’s telling that during the following season we actually accrued 13 points less than the previous campaign, the one that had seen the club nearly drop out of the Football League. The only reason we managed to survive despite this dismal points tally was because there were other sides that were even worse.’

During their time at Priestfield, Brighton were also compelled to pay a £500,000 bond to the Football League or face expulsion from the league system – levied in response to the financial crisis at the club and the loss of their ground.

‘That was money we could have really done without losing,’ admitted Knight. ‘Every penny mattered back then and to have the League punish the club and the fans for something that was in essence solely the fault of the previous regime was simply unfair.’

Brighton’s Return to the City at Withdean Stadium

Hamstrung by the ground-share, with the club’s finances in a parlous state and the fans facing a lengthy commute to watch home games, a return to Brighton in some capacity became of paramount importance to the new regime. The city wasn’t blessed with many suitable sites but eventually the new board managed to arrange one.

During the 1999/2000 season the club took residency at the Withdean Stadium, an athletics and county league football arena just outside the city centre. If you’re being kind then you could describe Withdean as ‘cosy’. Another, more accurate description would be ‘knackered’. The stadium has the dubious honour of being voted the fourth worst in English league football by The Observer. And that was after Brighton re-developed it.

Despite this, the team’s home-coming could still be seen as a triumph. With a little investment the run-down athletics arena was transformed into a workable 6,000-capacity football stadium, albeit one with a running track, a small covered North Stand and a large, open South Stand, a pretty dodgy pitch and some unappealing toilets.

‘It was great to be back in Brighton,’ Costa recalled. ‘Withdean might not have been an ideal stadium but at least we were home again. Dick Knight had promised a return and been true to his word.’

The club’s choice of Withdean hadn’t been universally popular in Brighton, specifically among nearby residents. To win over public opinion and get the local authority behind them, the club and the fans worked closely together through the ‘Bring Home the Albion’ campaign. This close connection between supporters and the board was all part of Knight’s philosophy about how clubs should operate, as Liz Costa recalled, ‘The contrast between Dick Knight and Archer could not have been starker. Dick had been in communication with the fans throughout the fight to keep the Goldstone. Once he gained control of the club, this collaborative approach never once diminished. All the supporters’ groups who had been involved in the protests against Archer were communicated with.

‘Dick was also happy to listen to ideas from the supporters and always willing to give you half an hour of his time if requested. How many football chairmen are willing to talk to a fan who has telephoned him on the off-chance of a chat? We had the sense that Dick had the good of the club paramount in his mind. He wasn’t enormously rich and the consortium didn’t bring huge amounts of cash, but it was communicated to us from the beginning that the new regime would create financial stability, keep us all in the loop and just as important for the fans, get the club back in Brighton and with our own ground.’

Building a New Home: The Road to Falmer Stadium

Over the following decade Brighton managed to put the bad old days behind them. While never spectacular, the finances of the club improved and Knight and his board sought whenever possible to run things in a prudent manner. On the football side, although Albion’s form was erratic, the club managed to fluctuate between the Championship and League 1; a huge improvement on what had occurred towards the latter end of the 1990s. At the same time, Dick Knight and the rest of the board were tirelessly working to complete the second part of their promise to the fans; the construction of a brand new ground.

The Falmer Stadium lies just outside the city, next to the small village of Falmer. From first seeking planning permission to the eventual opening of the stadium, this was a ten-year project. The site’s proximity to the South Downs National Park ensured that a raft of different interest groups opposed its construction, a degree of opposition that led to two public inquiries on this issue.

Liz Costa, ‘Dick Knight, the board and the supporters worked tirelessly to make the Falmer stadium a reality. We all pulled together to raise money, keep the issue alive in the press and get the support of the football authorities, other clubs and the various local councils involved. The stadium did not come easy and there were plenty of times when we thought it might not happen, but Dick led the way, inspiring us all and providing guidance and real leadership. And the end result is that we have a fantastic stadium, one that provides the club with the ability to generate the income that you need to compete at this level.’

Dick Knight’s Legacy at Brighton & Hove Albion

Knight eventually took a less active role at Brighton. Back in 2009 he stepped  down as chairman and left the board, his position filled by Tony Bloom, the club’s majority shareholder. But despite the change,  Knight’s role in saving  Brighton and his laying of the foundations for the club as it is today its not forgotten but those who followed the Seagulls during those frustrating years.

Liz Costa:  ‘It’s fair to say that were it not for Dick Knight there could very well be no Brighton & Hove Albion today. When he came along the club was in a mess and very likely to be heading for Conference football and the real possibility of one day folding. With the help of the fans, he helped rebuild this club from the bottom up’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is mandatory

This field is mandatory

This field is mandatory

There was an error submitting your message. Please try again.

Security Check

Invalid Captcha code. Try again.

 

©Copyright. All rights reserved.

Information icon

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.